Tom, Mitch Broughton and Adam McNicol all had their say but the ultimate deciding vote lay with the fans.
You chose a clear winner: 44% of votes naming the 2007 grand final victory over Port Adelaide as the best grand final across a dominant era for the Cats.
22% of voters selected the 2009 flag as as the best whilst 34% gave the chocolates to the 2011 premiership win over Collingwood - a match you can see replayed at Simonds Stadium on Friday February 26 as the Cats take on the Pies in their opening NAB Challenge match.
Stay tuned as we at geelongcats.com.au continue to debate the hot topics around the club in the coming weeks.